Baiting Hollow Real Estate

Welcome to Baiting Hollow, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Suffolk County, New York. This charming hamlet is part of the picturesque North Fork of Long Island, offering a perfect blend of serene landscapes and vibrant community life. Known for its stunning natural beauty, Baiting Hollow boasts lush vineyards, rolling hills, and breathtaking views of Long Island Sound, making it an idyllic retreat for nature lovers and wine enthusiasts alike.

Baiting Hollow is steeped in rich history, with roots dating back to the 17th century. Its quaint atmosphere is complemented by a warm community spirit, where neighbors become friends and every gathering feels like a celebration. The area is home to a variety of local businesses, from artisanal shops to cozy cafes, each contributing to the unique charm of this small town.

Outdoor enthusiasts will find plenty to love in Baiting Hollow. The nearby beaches and parks offer ample opportunities for hiking, biking, and picnicking, while the local wineries invite you to indulge in tastings and tours amidst picturesque vineyards. For those seeking a bit of adventure, the nearby Long Island Sound provides a playground for boating, fishing, and swimming.

Baiting Hollow is not just a place to live; it’s a lifestyle. With its blend of rural tranquility and access to urban conveniences, including shopping, dining, and cultural events in nearby towns, it’s no wonder that this charming hamlet is becoming a sought-after destination for homebuyers. Whether you’re looking for a weekend getaway or a permanent residence, Baiting Hollow welcomes you with open arms and endless possibilities. Come discover the magic of this enchanting community!

Newest Listings in Baiting Hollow

$747,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1028176 MLS

Every so often a home comes along that checks every box, and then adds a few you didn't even know were on your wish list! The wait is over...because this is that home! Designed with an open, airy floor plan, this beautifully maintained ranch offers 3 spacious bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms. Vaulted ceilings soar above the living room, dining room, and eat-in kitchen, creating an inviting sense of space, while beautiful hardwood flooring flows throughout. Enjoy year-round comfort with Central Air, Oil heat, and the peace of mind of a Newer Roof. But, what truly sets this home apart is the Seller Owned SOLAR PANEL System, included FREE and CLEAR. No lease, No commitments, just the potential to produce all the electricity you'll need! New Paver Walkways welcome you home and lead to the oversized 2 plus-car garage, while a full, partially finished basement provides even more space to enjoy. Then step outside and prepare to fall in love. Whether you're relaxing on the back deck, entertaining on the patio, gathering around the fire pit for s'mores and star gazing beneath the stars, or dreaming of the pool you've always wanted, this incredible backyard offers the space to make it happen! Completely Fenced in Yard. Plenty of Room for Pool and more! Better yet, the property backs to over 15 protected acres with the development rights sold (DRS), providing a peaceful backdrop and a level of privacy that's becoming increasingly difficult to find. Homes may offer features...the special ones, offer a feeling! Come experience the difference for yourself! Location: Conveniently located at the start of the North Fork in Beautiful Baiting Hollow. You also have easy access to multiple town beaches on the Bay or Sound, with convenient access to Ocean beaches, County Parks and numerous Marinas and Golf Courses. Come enjoy the Beautiful North Fork, its Gourmet Restaurants, Vineyard Wineries, Breweries, Retail shopping and Outlets, nearby Farmstands & Agricultural Attractions, and the endless year-round opportunities The North Fork provides!

124 Donna Drive, Baiting Hollow

$715,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1026327 MLS

Welcome to the spacious 3 bedroom, 2.5 Bathroom Townhouse in the Golf Villas in Baiting Hollow located in the Sound Front Community of Fox Hill. This beautifully maintained and updated home offers an open concept living with vaulted ceilings, 2 skylights and multiple sliding doors allowing for plenty of light leading to a private patio, great for entertaining. Enjoy your favorite beverage or book on a small balcony off the bedroom upstairs while enjoying the sights and sounds of nature. The kitchen features newly painted cabinets, quartz countertops, tiled backsplash, stainless steel appliances including a Bosch dishwasher, Viking gas range, new LED lighting, ceramic tiled floors in the kitchen and living areas, laundry area is equipped with a Maytag washer and dryer. All baths have been updated. Primary bedroom is located on the main level with an updated ensuite. Second level includes a den, great for a home office or extra guest space, an updated full bath and two spacious bedrooms, one offering a private balcony overlooking the patio. There is a finished storage/bonus area and a pull-down attic. Some other features of the home include 4 new ceiling fans, a newer gas hot water tank, a smart Nest thermostat and Smart Lock. Roof, siding, gutters, and deck are 5 years old. All blinds/curtains will remain. Residents at Fox Hill enjoy an abundance of amenities with include: a large community swimming pool, 4 Pickleball courts, 3 tennis courts, Bocci, playground and a pool house with a gym/exercise room, private sound front access for residents and their guests (yearly fee 125.00). This beautiful home is optimally located in the heart of the North Fork, minutes from many well-known wineries, excellent restaurants, farm stands, shopping, beaches and offers an abundance of recreational opportunities for everyone. Several golf courses, including Indian Island, Cherry Creek, and The Woods National are located minutes away. Experience the North Fork and all it offers in this move-in-ready Golf Villas Condominium

4010 The Fairway, Baiting Hollow

$125,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1022350 MLS

Mid-season opportunity in Woodcliff Park! This updated 2-bedroom, 1-bath seasonal cottage offers an ideal beach retreat in a desirable beachfront community open from April 15th through October 15th. Sold fully furnished and ready to enjoy, the home features vaulted ceilings, a remodeled kitchen, a bright dining area, comfortable living room, a full bath with tub, and two bedrooms. Enjoy the outdoor lifestyle with a covered front deck, private fenced rear deck, and private driveway parking for 2–3 cars. Just a short walk to the beach and close to wineries, farm stands, golf, horseback riding, Tanger Outlets, Splish Splash, the Long Island Aquarium, parks, trails, and more. Cash sales only. Land lease is separate from the sale and is currently $8,335.34 annually.

15 Whalers Path, Baiting Hollow

$499,990

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1021030 MLS

Welcome to 356 Oakleigh Ave #38, a modern coastal cottage nestled in the charming Baiting Hollow Cottages and Condominiums community. This unique property, completely rebuilt in 2023 from the ground up, marries the tranquility of beachfront living with the comforts of a contemporary home. The house features three spacious bedrooms, a versatile loft space perfect for an office or recreation room, and a well-appointed bathroom. The interior design is characterized by quality and style, from custom cabinetry and 3½-inch white oak flooring to Anderson 400 Series windows. Thoughtful details, such as sound-insulated walls, are just part of the Hi end construction. The heart of this home is a bright, open living space, where you can enjoy the modern, inviting atmosphere. The property boasts a new foundation, framing, electrical, plumbing, insulation, roof, and siding, offering the peace of mind of a newly constructed home, while preserving the charm of this unique beach community. Living in Baiting Hollow is about much more than just the house. This cottage is one of just 39 homes in a private waterfront community spread across approximately 16.9 acres of shared property. The community offers private beach access via stairs, leading to an impressive 913 linear feet of private beachfront. Residents also have access to community buildings, including a shower cottage and a recreation cottage, and a storage building. A playground and picnic area provide opportunities for outdoor fun, while the private roads ensure a sense of exclusivity and security. Ownership costs are surprisingly affordable, with property taxes of only $3,948 per year and community dues of approximately $2,300 per year. This makes it one of the most economical ways to enjoy waterfront community living on Long Island. Whether you're seeking a year-round residence, a weekend retreat, or a low-maintenance coastal home, this property offers a rare combination of quality construction, efficient living, and an exceptional beach lifestyle. Enjoy the breathtaking views of the Long Island Sound from your private beach, relax on your stunning porcelain patio, or store your essentials in the new shed on the property. Experience the peace and beauty of coastal living.

356 Oakleigh Avenue Unit #38, Baiting Hollow

$749,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1019114 MLS

Rarely available, this exceptional top-floor, end-unit residence is perched atop the easternmost edge of Fox Hill, offering one of the community's most coveted locations. Nestled against peaceful woodlands with sweeping views of the Long Island Sound, it delivers an exceptional combination of privacy, natural beauty, and coastal living that few homes in the community can match. A striking bank of sliding glass doors seamlessly connects the expansive wraparound deck to the sun-drenched interior, where skylights fill the home with natural light. The open-concept design flows effortlessly from the living room, anchored by a warm wood-burning fireplace, to the dining area and into the beautifully updated kitchen featuring shaker-style cabinetry, quartz countertops, and stainless-steel appliances—creating an ideal layout for both everyday living and effortless entertaining. The spacious primary suite serves as a private coastal retreat, thoughtfully positioned to capture serene water views and refreshing sea breezes, and opens directly onto the secluded deck, where the home's location creates an intimate outdoor sanctuary. Begin each morning with the sun rising over the Long Island Sound and unwind each evening in complete privacy, immersed in the tranquility of your own waterfront escape. Fox Hill offers a resort-inspired lifestyle with private beach access along the Long Island Sound, an Olympic-size swimming pool, clubhouse, fitness center, tennis, pickleball, bocce courts, and immediate access to the renowned Baiting Hollow Golf Club. Just minutes from the North Fork's celebrated wineries, farm stands, waterfront restaurants, and beaches, this remarkable residence offers the perfect blend of privacy, coastal beauty, and convenience.

103 Fox Hill Drive, Baiting Hollow

$664,900

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1016145 MLS

Elevated Living at Fox Hill – Where Every Sunset is a Masterpiece. Perched at the highest point in the community, this exquisitely renovated 2-bedroom, 2-bath condo offers unparalleled views of the Long Island Sound and the North Fork coastline. Watch the sun melt into the shimmering sound from your spacious deck – your private front-row seat to nature's daily spectacle. Step inside to discover the skylight-illuminated living space with beautiful wood floors and a wood burning fireplace. The gourmet eat-in kitchen features granite counters and stainless-steel appliances. The sumptuous primary suite features a walk-in, rainfall shower. Every detail in this top floor unit has been thoughtfully designed with an eye to sophisticated living. Recent upgrades include new high-efficiency central air conditioning and gas heat, plus a new water heater, which will provide comfort and efficiency for years to come. The Fox Hill lifestyle offers a resort-style pool, 3 tennis courts, 4 pickleball courts, bocce, clubhouse, workout room, and private beach access. Adjacent to the world-class Baiting Hollow golf club with a course designed by Robert Trent Jones. Convenient to the best wineries, dining and shopping on the North Fork. And only 90 minutes to NYC. This isn't just a home – it's your elevated escape.

215 Fox Hill Drive, Baiting Hollow

$769,999

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1015883 MLS

North Fork living awaits at The Bluffs at Fox Hill. Welcome to this beautifully updated top floor residence offering the perfect blend of relaxed luxury and resort style amenities in one of Baiting Hollow’s most sought after waterfront communities. Enjoy breathtaking water views, peaceful surroundings, and effortless living in this spacious condo featuring a layout designed for both everyday comfort and entertaining. The bright living area is anchored by a cozy fireplace and flows seamlessly into the dining space and kitchen creating an inviting atmosphere throughout. The condo offers 3 generously sized bedrooms, including a private primary suite with an updated bathroom with jacuzzi tub and separate shower. One of only a few units that offer the 3rd bedroom which is perfect for guests or an even a home office. Step outside onto your balcony and embrace the lifestyle with amazing views of the Long Island Sound, fresh coastal breezes and unforgettable sunsets. Residents of The Bluffs enjoy exceptional amenities including a pool, clubhouse with fitness center, pickleball and tennis courts, bocce, and private beach access. Ideally located just minutes from North Fork wineries, farm stands, golf, shopping, and dining with convenient access to Peconic Bay and the Hamptons. A rare opportunity to enjoy year round living or the perfect North Fork escape!

606 Fox Hill Drive, Baiting Hollow

$799,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1014667 MLS

Turn the key and unpack! Welcome to this beautifully renovated three-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath townhouse in the highly sought-after Golf Villas in Baiting Hollow, located within the prestigious Fox Hill Community. Thoughtfully updated with exceptional craftsmanship and premium finishes, this home offers the perfect blend of luxury, comfort, and convenience. Recent renovations include top-of-the-line finishes throughout, LED lighting, elegant crown molding, new interior doors, custom chefs kitchen, Graber plantation shutters, Levolor shades, hardwood and tile flooring, and ceiling fans. The designer kitchen features custom Plato cabinetry, stunning quartz countertops, and high-end finishes that will delight any home chef. The open-concept living and dining areas boast soaring cathedral ceilings, creating a bright, airy atmosphere with seamless access to the oversized stone patio—perfect for entertaining or relaxing outdoors. The first-floor primary suite offers the ease of one-level living and features a spacious bedroom and a beautifully appointed spa-like ensuite bath. Upstairs, you’ll find two additional bedrooms, including one with a private balcony overlooking the golf course and offering panoramic views. A finished bonus room provides the ideal space for a home office, den, or hobby room. Residents of Fox Hill enjoy an outstanding array of amenities, including: Community swimming pool, Pickleball and tennis courts, Bocce courts, Fitness center Private Sound-front beach access for residents and their guests Ideally situated in the heart of the North Fork, this exceptional home is just minutes from renowned wineries, farm stands, acclaimed restaurants, boutique shopping, beaches, and countless recreational opportunities. Several local golf courses are within 15 min of this home, including Cherry Creek, The Woods National and Indian Island. Experience luxury North Fork living at its finest in this move-in-ready Golf Villas condominium.

4004 The Fairway, Baiting Hollow

$1,100,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1010933 MLS

Located within Baiting Hollow Estates on Long Island's North Fork, this beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 3-bath Colonial offers the perfect blend of comfort, privacy, and coastal living. Set on 1.11 private acres with a wooded backyard, this inviting home features a spacious layout designed for both everyday living and entertaining. A grand foyer welcomes you into the home, where you'll find a formal dining room, a first-floor office or potential fourth bedroom, and a spacious family room with a gas fireplace. The updated eat-in kitchen is the heart of the home, showcasing stainless steel appliances, a large center island, updated cabinetry, backsplash, and skylights that fill the space with natural light. Additional skylights can also be found in the living area and guest bath. The second level features a generous primary suite with a tray ceiling, walk-in closet, and large en-suite bath, along with two additional bedrooms and full bath. Wood floors run throughout the home, complemented by plantation shutters in the bedrooms and office. Additional amenities include a large laundry room, central vacuum, central air conditioning, two-zone heating and cooling, oil heat with a new burner and water heater, situated on a corner lot with tons of privacy and beautifully landscaped, a full unfinished walk-out basement, and an oversized two-plus-car garage with pull-down attic access. Outdoor living is equally impressive with an oversized rear deck, wraparound front porch, charming gazebo, in-ground sprinklers, and plenty of room to enjoy the peaceful surroundings. Baiting Hollow Estates is comprised of 15 homes that share a gated and maintained staircase to 150 feet of a private beach. HOA dues are just $750 per year and include beach access, gate and lock maintenance, and upkeep of the community landscape circles. Close proximity to the North Fork, Hamptons, golf, boating, vineyards, and so much more.

216 Landing Lane, Baiting Hollow

$599,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1010214 MLS

Rarely available for sale, golf course views with 2 bedrooms and 2 baths. community features include but not limited to Tennis, Pickleball courts, pool, exercise facilities and access to beautiful Long Island Sound for residents. This unit has been lightly used since purchase...priced to sell!

4102 Fox Hill Drive, Baiting Hollow

$959,900

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1009184 MLS

Beautifully appointed contemporary home with refined transitional style, set on a private flag lot in Baiting Hollow. Tucked away from the road and surrounded by picturesque farm views, this light-filled residence offers a perfect blend of comfort, elegance, and privacy with a quiet ambience throughout. Vaulted ceilings, skylights, recessed lighting, maple hardwood floors, and crown molding enhance the home’s open and airy feel, making it ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. Past the foyer, the kitchen offers generous cabinetry, a center island, quartz countertops, and a stone backsplash, opening to the formal dining room and living room anchored by a propane ribbon fireplace with a wood mantel and natural stone surround. The lower level also adds exceptional versatility with a second sitting area, a flexible den or home office, hidden laundry space, and half bath—perfect for work, guests, or relaxation. Upstairs, you’ll find four spacious bedrooms, including a well-appointed primary suite featuring radiant heated floors, an oversized walk-in shower, spa tub, and a custom walk-in closet. A second ensuite bedroom offers added privacy and convenience. The hall bathroom includes a separate soaker tub, providing an additional spa-like retreat. All bathrooms throughout the home are enhanced with rain head showers, marble tile, glass shower enclosures, and thoughtfully designed built-in benches. Designed for indoor-outdoor living, the home opens to an expansive, low-maintenance Trex deck overlooking a secluded, professionally landscaped acre with sweeping sunset views and built -n fire pit Additional features include a two-car attached garage, in-ground sprinkler system, and an oversized storage shed. Ideally located near North Fork wineries, farms, shopping, golf courses, and beaches, this move-in-ready home delivers style, space, and serenity in a highly desirable setting, just minutes from major highways and transportation.

117 Southfield Road, Baiting Hollow

$699,999

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1010341 MLS

Welcome to 100 Donna Drive in the desirable Village Green community of Baiting Hollow! This beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch, built in 1993, offers comfortable one-level living with exceptional indoor and outdoor entertaining spaces. Step onto the inviting front porch and into a spacious floor plan featuring an oversized living room, a generously sized kitchen, and large bedrooms, including a primary suite with a private ensuite bath. The home also boasts a full basement with an outside separate entrance (OSE), providing abundant storage and excellent potential for extended living, recreational space, home office, or guest accommodations (subject to applicable permits). Outside, the property truly shines. The fully fenced backyard is a private retreat featuring a rear deck, patio, stunning in-ground saltwater pool, charming gazebo, and mature professional landscaping that creates a peaceful, park-like setting perfect for entertaining or relaxing. Additional highlights include a one-car attached garage, ample parking, oversized bedrooms, and meticulous pride of ownership throughout. Conveniently located near beaches, golf courses, vineyards, farm stands, shopping, dining, and all that the North Fork has to offer, this exceptional home combines privacy, comfort, and lifestyle in one beautiful package.

100 Donna Drive, Baiting Hollow

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.