Bayville Homes for Sale

Welcome to Bayville, New York—a hidden gem nestled along the picturesque North Shore of Long Island in Nassau County. This charming village offers a perfect blend of serene coastal living and vibrant community spirit. With its lush greenery, stunning waterfront views, and friendly atmosphere, Bayville is not just a place to live; it’s a lifestyle.

Bayville boasts a rich history and a multitude of recreational opportunities. Residents can enjoy the beautiful beaches, parks, and marinas, making it an ideal spot for boating, fishing, and sunbathing. The village is also home to a variety of local shops, cafes, and restaurants, ensuring that you have everything you need right at your doorstep. With top-rated schools and a strong sense of community, Bayville is perfect for families, professionals, and retirees alike.

If you’re considering making Bayville your home, you’re in luck! The real estate market here offers a diverse range of homes for sale, from charming bungalows to luxurious waterfront properties. Whether you’re searching for a cozy starter home or a spacious estate with stunning views, Bayville has something to suit every taste and budget.

Explore the tranquility of suburban living while still being conveniently located near major highways and public transportation, allowing for easy access to New York City and beyond. Discover your dream home in Bayville, where you can enjoy the best of both worlds—coastal charm and modern convenience. Your perfect home awaits in this idyllic village!

Newest Bayville Homes for Sale

$1,300,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1048006 MLS

Waterview Inspired Elegance on Mill Neck Creek Perched majestically just a block from the sparkling waters of Mill Neck Creek, this enchanting 1939 classic blends timeless architectural grace with modern warmth. Set on an elevated vantage point that captures sweeping, shimmering water views and gentle breezes, 10 Holden Lane is a rare coastal haven offering an idyllic lifestyle. A long, verdant driveway lined with lush evergreens and mature plantings welcomes you home, setting a private and serene tone. Step up to the inviting spacious porch, the ultimate spot to unwind with your morning coffee while taking in the active, picturesque water views right outside your door. Property Highlights Main Residence: A thoughtfully curated 1939 layout featuring a spacious formal living room and dining room, a sun-drenched sunroom flanked by two fireplaces (one on each side), and rich character throughout. Flexible Accommodation: Includes a convenient first-floor bedroom and full bathroom, three well-proportioned bedrooms on the second level, and an additional bedroom and bath on the lower level. Detached Cottage: Exceptionally spacious, featuring a grand bedroom with high ceilings, a full bath, a full kitchen, and an open-concept living area,ideal for guests, extended family, or a private home office. Prime Waterfront Proximity: The property extends all the way down to the street just steps from Mill Neck Creek, placing the water practically in your front yard.

10 Holden Lane, Bayville

$500,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1040651 MLS

Tucked away on the North Shore of Long Island in Bayville, just a short stroll from the Creek beach, is a 2 story, 2 bedroom cottage on a 50 x 100 lot. Use your imagination to renovate or reconstruct in this seaside village which offers boating, swimming, kayaking, tennis/pickle ball courts. Enjoy the many wonderful shops & restaurants.

6 Cross Road, Bayville

$499,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1038237 MLS

Great Potential! This two-story, 2 bedroom/ 1.5 bath home presents a fantastic opportunity for those looking to bring their vision to life. A property with endless possibilities!

38 Jackson Avenue, Bayville

$1,399,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1037944 MLS

Welcome to an exceptional new construction residence overlooking the serene waters of Mill Neck Creek. This beautifully appointed Colonial blends timeless architectural details with sophisticated modern finishes, creating an elegant yet inviting home. A dramatic entrance foyer with a soaring 20-foot ceiling sets the tone upon arrival. Throughout the residence, 9-foot ceilings and rich oak hardwood floors add warmth and scale. The gracious living room features custom electric window shades, while the elegant dining room is enhanced by a striking custom chandelier. The chef’s kitchen is designed for both entertaining and everyday living, featuring quartz countertops, custom cabinetry and fixtures, a marble backsplash, stainless steel appliances, and a farmhouse sink. A generous center island is illuminated by two stylish pendant lights. Sliding glass doors open directly to the patio, creating an effortless transition to outdoor dining and entertaining. Adjacent to the kitchen, the inviting den provides a cozy retreat with a fireplace and an abundance of natural sunlight. Thoughtfully designed with comfort, style, and entertaining in mind, this exceptional residence offers a sophisticated Gold Coast lifestyle. Not located in a flood zone. Locust Valley School District. Ideally situated in close proximity to beaches, shopping, dining, and transportation.

9 Hickory Road, Bayville

$879,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1043308 MLS

This is your opportunity to own a home in the sought-after beach community of Bayville. Well maintained and cared for over the years, this charming Colonial-style home offers timeless character and plenty of opportunity to make it your own. Featuring a welcoming wrap-around porch, approximately 0.3 acres of property, and impressive ceiling height, the home offers a wonderful sense of space and character. The home has been thoughtfully updated with a conversion to gas heat less than five years ago, a tankless hot water heater, sprinkler system, and central air conditioning on the first floor. An added benefit of being in Flood Zone X is that flood insurance is not required, offering additional peace of mind for the next owner. Enjoy everything Bayville has to offer, from beautiful beaches and boating to waterfront restaurants, marinas, local shops, and attractions. Experience the relaxed atmosphere and charm of a true North Shore beach community, where coastal living and small-town character come together.

104 Bayville Avenue, Bayville

$885,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1040406 MLS

Enjoy coastal living in this beautifully situated 3-bedroom, 2-bath raised ranch in one of Bayville’s most desirable locations, complete with private beach access to the Long Island Sound. Truly move-in ready with nothing to do but unpack and enjoy, this home offers comfortable living, thoughtful updates, and an exceptional setting just steps from the water. The main level features a spacious kitchen with center island and adjoining dining area, along with a large living room highlighted by a wood-burning fireplace and sliding doors that open to a balcony with water views. Three generously sized bedrooms and a full bathroom complete the main floor. The recently refinished lower level offers excellent flexibility for additional living space, a home office, guest area, or recreation room. A second full bathroom and direct access to the attached two-car garage add to the home’s functionality and convenience. Outside, the backyard is ready for entertaining with a new patio with electric retractable awning. Raised flower beds and storage shed make this yard a gardener's dream. Other notable features include newer heating and central AC systems, whole home water filtration system, home alarm, and in-ground sprinklers. With its move-in-ready condition, private beach access, spacious layout, and sought-after location, this home offers an incredible opportunity to enjoy the very best of North Shore living. Locust Valley Schools.

5 Willow Street, Bayville

$599,999

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1037660 MLS

This charming 3-bedroom, 2-full-bath offers a relaxed coastal lifestyle. The home features a partially open floor plan for comfortable living and dining spaces with plenty of natural light. A south-facing enclosed porch provides a bright, sun-filled space to enjoy throughout the day. Out back, enjoy a cozy deck and outdoor shower—perfect after a day at the beach. Association membership provides access to a private beach, adding another great feature to the home's coastal setting. Best of all, you're just three blocks from the heart of Bayville Village, where you'll find popular restaurants, public beaches, the Bayville Scream Park, an arcade and local attractions. This house offers a wonderful combination of beach access, outdoor living, village convenience and classic Bayville charm. With a little TLC and your dream visions you can make this your ideal home.

305 Bayville Avenue, Bayville

$549,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1021442 MLS

This 3 bedroom 2 bath cottage offers very low taxes and a rare opportunity for a 1st time homebuyers, a retirees, and interested builders. A legal income income producing rental. This home is part of the Bayville Locust Valley School district. Steps away from Cresent Beach Club, beautiful beaches, shopping and restaurants. The house has cozy kitchen with gas stove, dining & living room, a full finish basement with washer & dryer. There is also backyard shed. A room for entertaining. A fantastic price in a relaxed, friendly beachfront community. Will not last.

44 Perry Avenue, Bayville

$1,499,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1037014 MLS

magnificent totally redone colonial, sits on half acre of totally private yard with mature planting,this home features brand new shaker kitchen with high end ss appliances, formal dining room with built ins, den with vaulted ceiling an skylite an brick fireplace, formal living room with fireplace, large den,new half bath, 2nd floor has 3 bedrooms on one wing an master bedroom features new full bath an door leading out to 2nd floor deck with new trex decking an white railing,in addition private stairs leading to second floor has bedroom an new full bath,the basement has large finished room laundry area,new bilco doors for easy access for large items outdoor furniture etc , new heating system ,new 3 zone central air,new electric service, new roof, all new siding, outside area for table an chairs totally covered this home has so many features must must be seen oh an just a few homes away from long island sound no flood insurance needed on high elevation,has stairs to 3rd floor plenty of storage.

28 Wayaawi Avenue, Bayville

$699,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1033273 MLS

Welcome to this exceptionally spacious High Ranch, with endless possibilities in a Prime Bayville Location! Ideally situated on a private cul-de-sac in the desirable Locust Valley School District. Set on an oversized property just moments from Bayville's beautiful beaches, this home presents a rare opportunity to create the home you've always imagined. Inside, you'll find generously proportioned rooms, a versatile floor plan, and abundant living space designed to accommodate a variety of lifestyles. Whether you're looking to renovate, modernize, or customize to your own, the possibilities are endless. This expansive property offers ample space for outdoor entertaining and recreation, making it the perfect canvas for your vision. If you've been searching for a home with loads of potential in an exceptional location, this is an opportunity you won't want to miss. Bring your imagination and transform this diamond in the rough into the home of your dreams. Property is being sold "AS IS"

1 Karen Court, Bayville

$999,999

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1034512 MLS

Coastal charm meets endless potential in the picturesque Village of Bayville! Situated on a quiet exclusive street just steps away from a private resident-only beach, this spacious Colonial offers a peaceful retreat. Features generous living spaces and a master suite already rough-plumped for its own private bathroom- finishing this project creates a 3- bathroom home! Motivat

13 Meadow Lane, Bayville

$1,061,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1022597 MLS

A Rare Bayville Carriage House with an Automotive Enthusiast's Dream Garage... Welcome to 3 Finnin Place, a distinctive 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home located in the beautiful Gold Coast beach community of Bayville, NY on Long Island's North Shore. Combining architectural character, coastal living, and an extraordinary oversized heated two car garage, this unique Bayville property offers features rarely found together in one home. Tucked away on a dead-end street with just four homes, the residence features an inviting open floor plan highlighted by dramatic vaulted ceilings, exposed beams, and a beautiful wood-burning fireplace. The main living, dining, and kitchen areas flow seamlessly together, creating an impressive gathering space for everyday living and entertaining. The updated primary suite features an en-suite bathroom, while two additional bedrooms and flexible living areas provide versatility throughout the home. Additional features include central vacuum, generous storage, and distinctive architectural details. CAR COLLECTORS & AUTOMOTIVE ENTHUSIASTS—THIS GARAGE DESERVES YOUR ATTENTION! The fully heated, oversized garage is an exceptional feature for anyone searching for a Long Island home with serious garage, workshop, or automobile storage space. Approximately 12-foot ceilings, oversized garage doors, 220V electrical capability, and generous interior clearance provide incredible flexibility and potential to accommodate a vehicle lift, subject to proper installation and applicable requirements. Whether you're a car collector looking for a home with an oversized 2 car garage, an automotive enthusiast seeking workshop space, or simply want exceptional heated garage and storage capacity, 3 Finnin Place offers a combination that can be difficult to find on Long Island's North Shore. Beyond the home, enjoy the distinctive lifestyle of Bayville, NY—a beautiful Gold Coast coastal community with convenient access to beaches, waterfront recreation, parks, boating, restaurants, shops, and the scenic surroundings of Long Island's North Shore. From the oversized heated three-car garage and vehicle-lift potential to the open-concept interior, vaulted ceilings, exposed beams, and coastal Bayville setting, 3 Finnin Place offers a truly unique opportunity to enjoy North Shore living without leaving your passion for cars, collections, and hobbies behind.

3 Finnin Place, Bayville

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.