Fair Harbor Real Estate

Welcome to Fair Harbor, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Suffolk County, New York. This enchanting seaside community is located on Fire Island, a barrier island renowned for its pristine beaches, vibrant natural landscapes, and tranquil atmosphere. With a population of just a few hundred residents, Fair Harbor offers a unique blend of charm and serenity, making it the perfect retreat for those looking to escape the hustle and bustle of city life.

Fair Harbor is characterized by its picturesque boardwalks, charming beach cottages, and an inviting sense of community. The area is primarily car-free, allowing for a peaceful and relaxed environment where families and friends can stroll along sandy paths, breathe in the salty sea air, and enjoy the stunning views of the Atlantic Ocean. The local beaches are ideal for sunbathing, swimming, and beachcombing, while the nearby maritime forests provide excellent opportunities for hiking and wildlife observation.

The community is also home to a few delightful eateries and shops, ensuring you have everything you need at your fingertips. Whether you're indulging in fresh seafood at a local restaurant or picking up artisanal goods from a quaint shop, Fair Harbor offers a taste of coastal living that is hard to resist.

For those seeking a close-knit community with a strong sense of belonging, Fair Harbor is the perfect place to call home. With its breathtaking scenery, friendly atmosphere, and a lifestyle that celebrates the beauty of nature, this idyllic location is truly a slice of paradise waiting for you to discover. Come and experience the magic of Fair Harbor—you may just find your forever home here!

Newest Listings in Fair Harbor

$825,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1006762 MLS

Located just five houses from the ocean in Fair Harbor, this 2 bedroom, 1 bath home offers a classic Fire Island setting with privacy and a desirable beachside location. Surrounded by mature landscaping, the property features a spacious deck and outdoor seating area, providing a comfortable place to enjoy the outdoors. Inside, the home offers a bright living area, hardwood floors, an eat-in kitchen, and a functional layout that captures the relaxed character of the Fire Island lifestyle. Just a short walk to the ocean, this is an opportunity to own a well maintained Fair Harbor cottage in one of the community's most sought-after locations.

111 Walnut Walk, Fair Harbor

$2,999,999

1000213 MLS ⋅ Pioneer Market BLDG.

Located in the heart of Fair Harbor’s vibrant downtown, Fair Harbor Market represents a rare opportunity to acquire one of Fire Island’s most established and successful grocery businesses. Serving the neighboring communities of Fair Harbor, Dunewood, Lonelyville, Atlantique, Saltaire, and Kismet, the market has been a cornerstone of Fire Island’s west end since 1968, operating as the area’s primary destination for groceries, prepared foods, deli service, meats, seafood, beach essentials, and everyday conveniences for generations of residents and summer visitors. Operating annually from May through October, the business benefits from steady, high-volume seasonal traffic in one of Fire Island’s most active and socially vibrant communities, known for its beach culture, lively summer atmosphere, and iconic sunset views. Offered together with the commercial real estate, this is a true turnkey investment opportunity featuring both a thriving business and an exceptionally well-positioned commercial property in a highly sought-after location. The market is thoughtfully laid out for efficient, high-volume operation and features four main grocery aisles, dedicated deli cases, and a large beverage section, creating a comprehensive shopping experience for both residents and vacationers. Behind the deli counter, a walk-in refrigeration box supports seamless food preparation and storage operations. The property is further equipped with a computerized house account system, ATM, commercial ice machine, new cooking hood with integrated fire suppression system, electric grill, walk-in freezer, dual walk-in coolers, extensive refrigerated display cases for dairy, meat, beer, beverages, frozen foods, and ice cream, as well as multiple box freezers and a high-capacity commercial ice maker. An adjoining breakfast, lunch, and ice cream window generates consistent foot traffic throughout the day and evening, while the second-floor two-bedroom apartment offers valuable owner accommodations, staff housing, or rental income potential. A longstanding Fire Island institution with nearly six decades of operating history, Fair Harbor Market offers the opportunity to own an iconic and deeply rooted business at the center of one of Fire Island’s most desirable summer communities.

21 Broadway, Fair Harbor

$1,175,000

1003608 MLS

A rare opportunity to own land in one of Fire Island's most beloved communities. Fair Harbor offers a classic beach town feel with easy ocean and bay access, a tight-knit neighborhood vibe, and a strong summer rental market. This is two separate parcels being sold together as one. This property is on the east side of Fifth Avenue on the bay side.

A 5 Avenue, Fair Harbor

$1,500,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1003498 MLS

You will love the details that make this architectural gem one of a kind. Located on a quiet walk with access to the bay, this beach house offers a peaceful, private setting that is highly sought after. A pathway brings you to a pretty entry vestibule. Sliders open to a partially covered courtyard which provides a wonderful place for the outdoor dining table. This breezeway between the 2 sections of the house perfectly divides the sleeping and living areas. Abundant windows, skylights and sliding doors bring sunlight into every room. High ceilings, white finishes and beautiful hardwood floors give this house a serene and airy feel. Cross breezes, ceiling fans and AC keep you cool when you need it. There are 2 bedrooms in the main house. The primary bedroom has a private full bath. There is another full bath that has deck access and one other bedroom. A white brick fire place splits the living area giving you a comfortable gathering room and a media lounging spot. A dining table is tucked close to the galley kitchen. The separate guest house offers additional accommodations and includes its own private deck, a lofty main room, a half bath, and a cozy sleeping loft accessible by stairs. This charming space comfortably sleeps up to 4 guests. This exceptional beach house was designed with outdoor living in mind. The deck and patio areas, which can be accessed from almost every room, provide the perfect outdoor spaces to relax and enjoy the surrounding beauty of the garden. A screened in patio structure gives you a protected lounge area with cushioned sofas.

40 Elm Walk, Fair Harbor

$1,699,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 993135 MLS

Turn Key

28 Oak Walk, Fair Harbor

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.