Fire Island Pines Homes for Sale

Welcome to Fire Island Pines, a hidden gem nestled along the pristine shores of New York’s Suffolk County. This enchanting community is renowned for its stunning natural beauty, vibrant social scene, and a lifestyle that perfectly blends relaxation with recreation. Accessible only by ferry, Fire Island Pines offers a unique escape from the hustle and bustle of city life, making it a coveted destination for those seeking tranquility and charm.

The picturesque landscape is adorned with sandy beaches, lush maritime forests, and captivating sunsets that paint the sky in hues of orange and pink. Whether you’re strolling along the boardwalks, enjoying a day at the beach, or indulging in the local dining scene, Fire Island Pines is brimming with opportunities for leisure and enjoyment.

For those considering a move to this idyllic locale, there are a variety of homes for sale that cater to diverse tastes and preferences. From modern beach cottages to luxurious waterfront properties, each home offers its own unique charm and character. Imagine waking up to the sound of waves lapping at the shore, sipping your morning coffee on a sun-drenched deck, and hosting unforgettable gatherings with friends and family in your very own slice of paradise.

With a tight-knit community and a vibrant social calendar that includes art events, music festivals, and themed parties, Fire Island Pines is not just a place to live; it’s a lifestyle. Explore the homes for sale today, and discover the perfect retreat where you can create lasting memories in this enchanting coastal haven. Your dream home awaits!

Newest Fire Island Pines Homes for Sale

$950,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1046904 MLS

Attention first time homebuyers. Outstanding opportunity to purchase midcentury starter house in the Pines. 3bedrooms, 2 baths, open living / dining space. Ample deck space including hot tub and panoramic roof terrace featuring bay views.

480 Tarpon Walk, Fire Island Pines

$925,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1046121 MLS

The perfect Pines starter house. 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, large open living space featuring screened porch. Ample room to add a pool and additional decking.

176 Fire Island Avenue, Fire Island Pines

$3,500,000

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1045873 MLS

Set directly on the Atlantic in the coveted low 400s of Fire Island Pines, this contemporary oceanfront residence combines exceptional beachfront living with modern construction and year-round functionality. Built from the ground up in 2016 to post-Hurricane Sandy elevation and building standards, the fully permitted home offers three ocean-facing en-suite bedrooms, 3.5 baths, a heated saltwater pool, rooftop hot tub and private beach access via its own boardwalk. The open main living level features 11-foot ceilings, hardwood floors, expansive ocean-facing glass and a wood-burning fireplace. The kitchen is equipped with high-end appliances including a 36-inch refrigerator, gas range, wall oven, dishwasher, wine cooler and dedicated ice maker. Glass doors open directly to the oceanfront deck and heated saltwater pool, creating a seamless connection between the interior, outdoor living spaces and beach beyond. Upstairs, all three en-suite bedrooms enjoy ocean views and private balconies. Two are generously proportioned primary suites, while the rooftop terrace and hot tub offer panoramic views across the Atlantic and the Pines. Fully winterized with substantial heated storage beneath the home, recently replaced HVAC condensers and refinished hardwood floors. Extensively updated during the current ownership and offered fully furnished, excluding artwork. A turnkey oceanfront home designed for long summers, shoulder seasons and life in the Pines throughout the year.

418 Ocean Walk, Fire Island Pines

$1,695,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1043341 MLS

Impeccably maintained, secluded Bay Walk property located eight minutes from the Waterfront. Renovated in 2025 including kitchen appliances; cabinetry; refinished hardwood floors; heated XL saltwater pool; hot tub; gas water heater; roof and fully serviced Andersen windows & doors. New furnishings throughout. Extensive mahogany decking. Wood burning fireplace and propane fire pit. Fully air conditioned. Generously proportioned primary en-suite features with additional fireplace. Three guest bedrooms (one king & two queen beds) with ample closets. Low operating expenses and $185k in 2026 gross rent; several weeks pre-booked in 2027. Straightforward mortgage financing – no open permits, violations, and conforming to zoning requirements. Being sold fully furnished & turnkey.

279 Bay Walk, Fire Island Pines

$1,650,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1041244 MLS

Set amongst lush landscaping, 208 Midway Walk is a commanding presence with a storied history and architectural pedigree attributed to Bates Masi+ Architects. Cedar detailing inside and out presents 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths, double height ceilings and large windows bringing the indoors out. Extra deep lot and large pool + morning and afternoon decks, sun and shade options, makes for the ideal Fire Island retreat.

208 Midway Walk, Fire Island Pines

$3,300,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1038274 MLS

One of Fire Island Pines’ most recognizable residences, the Pyramid House is an extraordinary expression of the experimental modernism that came to define the Pines. Designed circa 1960 by Buenos Aires–born architect Julio Kaufman, the house was later thoughtfully reimagined while preserving Kaufman’s iconic silhouette. A monumental steel-and-glass wall opens the soaring upper-level great room to sweeping views across the protected dunes of Fire Island National Seashore toward the Atlantic and bay beyond. Set at the quiet eastern edge of the Pines and bordering protected landscape, the approximately 2,100-square-foot residence offers an unusual degree of privacy. Built to a standard uncommon to Fire Island, its robust construction includes galvanized structural steel designed to endure the island environment. The current configuration offers three bedrooms and two-and-a-half baths. The lower level is devoted principally to an expansive primary suite with dressing areas, bath and private study, opening toward the pool and dunes. Across the secluded courtyard, three smaller pyramidal forms echo the geometry of the original house, with two guest bedrooms flanking a central bath. Recent improvements include central air conditioning, significant electrical upgrades, a new saltwater pool liner and updated pool mechanicals, along with 3M Prestige 70 window film applied to the Pyramid’s monumental glazing. For its next steward, the expansive lower level presents the possibility of another chapter of reinvention, potentially accommodating two additional ensuite bedrooms and creating a five-bedroom, four-and-a-half-bath residence.* The property’s successful history as a sought-after seasonal rental adds another dimension to its versatility. More than six decades after its creation, the Pyramid House remains remarkably private and unmistakably iconic—a landmark of Fire Island modernism ready for its next chapter. *Any potential reconfiguration is subject to applicable approvals and independent verification by the purchaser.

443 Sail Walk, Fire Island Pines

$2,200,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1033182 MLS

THE BEST THE PINES HAS TO OFFER. Gorgeous contemporary 2 bedroom, 3 bath offering seamless indoor/outdoor living. Private and luxurious the many amenities include a large heated pool & spacious deck, hot tub, central AC and heat, fireplace, television room that can be converted into a third bedroom & designer furnishings all set in beautifully landscaped gardens.

307 Shady Walk, Fire Island Pines

$1,995,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1026332 MLS

Mid-century modernism as seen through the eyes of Horace Gifford. This 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath features all the modern & sophisticated hallmarks of Giffords genius - clean lines, open living space and seamless indoor/outdoor flow. All set in a private garden with large pool and multi purpose decking.

487 Tarpon Walk, Fire Island Pines

$1,599,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1024478 MLS

Welcome to 77 Bay Walk, a beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath home in the heart of Fire Island Pines. Designed for effortless indoor-outdoor living, this inviting retreat features an open floor plan, abundant natural light, and two wood-burning fireplaces that add warmth and character. Step outside to your own private oasis with a saltwater swimming pool, hot tub, expansive sun decks, and beautifully landscaped gardens—perfect for entertaining or relaxing in complete privacy. Ideally located just moments from the bay, ocean beaches, and the vibrant Pines community, this exceptional property offers the perfect blend of comfort, style, and resort-style living. Whether you’re seeking a seasonal getaway, investment property, or your own island escape, 77 Bay Walk is a rare opportunity to own a piece of Fire Island Pines.

77 Bay Walk, Fire Island Pines

$1,650,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1013751 MLS

Originally designed for renowned visionary Irving Cooperberg and masterfully built by William Katen in 1991, this timeless Fire Island Pines Contemporary has only grown more distinguished with age. Meticulously maintained and thoughtfully enhanced throughout the years, the home offers sweeping ocean views, exceptional privacy, and the effortless indoor-outdoor lifestyle that defines the very best of Fire Island living. Entertain and unwind across two levels of outdoor living and dining space, relax in the secluded garden hot tub, or take advantage of direct beach access just moments from your door. Perfectly positioned on prestigious Beach Hill Walk, the property enjoys a coveted location between the ocean and the vibrant communities of Fire Island Pines and our beloved sister community, Cherry Grove. Private. Exclusive. Handsome. Timeless. With a strong and proven rental history, 136 Beach Hill Walk offers not only an extraordinary lifestyle opportunity but also compelling investment potential. As interest and investment in Fire Island Pines continues to grow, perhaps it is your turn to become part of this remarkable community. NEW PHOTOS COMING SOON.

136 Beach Hill Walk, Fire Island Pines

$1,275,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1013722 MLS

Perched high and dry on the secondary dune with sensational ocean views this 2 bedroom 2 bathroom mid-century cottage presents an ideal opportunity for first time home buyers. The many amenities include 30'x14' solar heated pool, hot tub, outdoor shower, out door grill & primary bedroom with ensuite bath.

445 Sail Walk, Fire Island Pines

$2,500,000

6 Beds ⋅ 7 Baths ⋅ 1006861 MLS

Perched high on the secondary dune on a corner lot we are pleased to offer Pines Bluff Overlook Guest House for sale. Comprised of 6 private guest suites all with ensuite baths. The many amenities include ,Apple TV, Central Air Conditioning, Fireplace, Heat, Hot Tub, Ocean Views, Outdoor Shower, Pool, Roof Deck, Wet Bar & Wifi.

362 Ocean Walk, Fire Island Pines

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.